Smoker Pellets – What Goes With What?

Hey Smokers, and welcome to my post where we will look into the types and uses on smoker pellets and what goes with what? As you may or may not know, this site is all about cooking on my Traeger Pro Series 22 Pellet Smoker and seeing where we can take things.

Smoker Pellets - Header

And as someone who at time of writing is still relatively new to the whole smoker and pellet thing, choosing the right pellets is definitely something that I have had to consider as my cooking repertoire grows. I mean i did have some idea based on my old charcoal smoker use, however it is the experimentation here that has had me intrigued…

So, How Do I Choose My Smoker Pellets?

To be honest, regardless of the type of smoker you are using, the best flavored wood pellets you choose are generally dependent on two factors:

  1. The type of meat you are cooking – this is where recommendations come in
  2. Personal taste – some wood types produce a stronger wood flavor than others

If you are new to the whole smoking thing, then you would usually start at the first step above. Here, all you need to do is do an online search along the lines of “what pellets are used to smoke pork ribs?”. Alternatively, go to a BBQ shop and look on the pellet bag where there is usually a little graphic that tells you what you can use that particular type for.

And in case your internet search brings you here, I have attached a guide from the Traeger website to help you match the right type of pellet with various meats below:

Smoker Pellets - Traeger list

Source: https://www.traeger.com/learn/wood-pellet-guide

But What If I Want to Experiment?

Isn’t that part of the fun? I have started trying different types of pellets with different meats and whilst I can’t always really tell the difference too much, I am starting to notice subtle flavor variations in the final outputs – especially in ‘softer’ meat such as pork or chicken.

I can also definitely tell if I use pellets that are too strong for the food in the smoker (such as I did with fish a few week back). So, if this is where you are at, here is a quick out line of the difference types of pellets you can try:

Hickory

Hickory pellets are a staple in the world of smoking and grilling (and my go-to), favored for their strong, hearty smoke flavor that’s particularly well-suited to a variety of meats. Here’s an overview:

  • Robust Smoke Flavor: Hickory pellets offer a strong, savory smoke flavor that is more pronounced than many other woods, such as oak or fruitwoods.
  • Rich Taste: The smoke from hickory pellets imparts a hearty, slightly sweet, and bacon-like flavor, making it a popular choice for many traditional barbecue dishes such as pork.

All in all, Hickory is versatile and can be used with beef, pork, chicken, and even game meats for those looking for the favor of the meat rather than the smoke.

My experience

I have listed this first as it is my go-to for general use when I just want a good, solid flavor without too much consideration (or care) about the delicacies of milder types. I really like it with pork butt myself!


Mesquite

Mesquite pellets are known for their strong and distinctive flavor, making them a favorite choice for grilling and smoking, especially in Southwestern and Texas-style cuisines predominately with beef. Here are the key characteristics:

  • Bold Smoke Flavor: Mesquite pellets provide a strong, earthy smoke flavor that is more intense than many other wood types, such as oak or apple.
  • Distinctive Taste: The smoke from mesquite pellets imparts a hearty, slightly sweet flavor that can significantly influence the taste of the food.

The strong flavor of mesquite pairs best with robust meats. It’s excellent for adding depth to beef and can also complement lamb and game meats.

My experience

I use mesquite for my beef ribs and also recently on Lamb Shoulder. I have done lamb shoulder with both mesquite and hickory and I could definitely taste the stronger elements of the mesquite when I used it. I really liked it but if you want a more delicate taste, stick to the hickory.


Apple

I use Apple pellets a lot in my pork (as my family like the lighter smoke flavor here) and they are highly regarded in the world of smoking and grilling for their subtle, sweet, and mildly fruity smoke flavor. Apple characteristics include:

  • Mild and Sweet Smoke: Apple wood pellets provide a gentle, subtly sweet smoke that is less intense than many hardwoods, such as hickory or oak.
  • Fruity Flavor: The smoke from apple pellets adds a light fruity flavor that can enhance the natural taste of food without dominating it.

Apple pellets are versatile and can be used with pork, poultry, and even delicate meats like lamb, imparting a delicate sweetness that complements the meat’s flavors.

My Experience

As above, this is another staple of mine and I like it for milder meats such as chicken and pork (or to be honest, when i run out of Hickory). I like it with pork ribs as well.

Note: The rest of this list is made ip of pellet types that I have to admit hat I have not tried as yet in my smoker. Some because I tended to stick with what I knew and others simply because they are not available where I shop. I will of course update this post as I try them but for now, here is a quick outline!


Oak

Oak pellets are a popular choice for grilling and smoking due to their versatility and the distinct flavor profile they offer. Here are the main characteristics:

  • Medium Smoke Flavor: Oak pellets provide a medium intensity smoke that is less overpowering than hickory or mesquite, making it suitable for a wide range of meats and dishes.
  • Balanced Taste: They impart a smooth, balanced smoky flavor.

Cherry

Cherry pellets are favored in the smoking and grilling community for their ability to impart a mild, sweet and fruity smoke flavor to a wide variety of foods. Here are the characteristics:

  • Mild and Sweet Smoke: Cherry wood pellets provide a gentle, sweet smoke that is less intense than hardwoods like hickory or mesquite, making it suitable for a broad range of dishes.
  • Fruity Flavor: The smoke from cherry pellets adds a subtle fruity flavor that can enhance the natural taste of the food without overpowering it.

As with apple, cherry pellets are versatile enough to be used with beef, pork, poultry and even game meats as well. Additionally, due to their mild flavor, cherry pellets can be mixed with stronger woods like oak or hickory to create a more complex flavor profile.


Pecan

Pecan pellets are known and cherished for their unique flavor profile, offering a rich, sweet, and nutty smoke that stands out without overpowering the food. Characteristics of pecan pellets include:

  • Rich and Sweet Smoke: Pecan wood pellets provide a medium-intensity smoke that is richer and slightly sweeter than many hardwoods, but not as intense as hickory or mesquite.
  • Nutty Flavor: The smoke from pecan pellets adds a distinct nutty and sweet flavor that can enhance the natural taste of food, offering a unique twist compared to more traditional smoking woods.

Pecan pellets are versatile and can be used with beef, pork, poultry and game meats, imparting a depth of flavor that complements the meat’s natural tastes. And as with cherry above, pecan pellets can be mixed with other woods like oak or apple to create a more complex flavor profile, balancing sweetness and smoke.


Maple

This probably makes sense, but Maple pellets are a favorite choice for those who prefer a lighter, sweeter smoke flavor in their barbecue. Here’s a run through:

  • Mild and Sweet Smoke: Maple wood pellets provide a gentle, subtly sweet smoke that is less intense than many other woods.
  • Slightly Smoky, Sweet Flavor: The smoke from maple pellets adds a light, sweet flavor that can enhance the natural taste of food, offering a hint of smokiness without the bitterness that stronger woods might impart.

Maple pellets are versatile and can be used with pork, poultry, and even delicate meats like fish, imparting a delicate sweetness that complements the meat’s flavors.


Alder

Recently, I was given some fish by my neighbor and wanted to know how to smoke it. Every recipe I found highlighted Alder pellets as the best pellets for smoking fish as they are known for their light, delicate smoke flavor, making them particularly well-suited for seafood. Here’s an overview:

  • Mild and Subtle Smoke: Alder wood pellets provide a gentle, subtly sweet smoke that is less intense than many other woods, making it ideal for enhancing the flavor of a wide range of foods without overpowering them.
  • Light, Slightly Sweet Flavor: The smoke from alder pellets adds a clean, mild sweetness that can complement the natural taste of food, particularly highlighting the delicate flavors of fish and seafood.

As above, alder pellets are especially well-suited for smoking fish such as salmon, trout and other seafood but can also be used with chicken and other light meats as well.

what pellet goes with what - hickory and apple pellets

What If I have The Meat First?

Well then, here is a quick guide for you to help you choose the right pellets.

1. Beef

  • Hickory: Offers a strong, traditional smoke flavor that pairs well with beef.
  • Mesquite: Provides a bold and earthy taste, great for brisket and steaks, but should be used sparingly due to its intensity.
  • Oak: A versatile choice that gives a medium smoke flavor, enhancing the meat’s natural flavors without overpowering.

2. Pork

  • Apple: Delivers a sweet, fruity smoke that complements pork’s natural sweetness, ideal for ribs and pork shoulders.
  • Cherry: Similar to apple, cherry wood pellets offer a slightly sweeter and fruitier smoke, perfect for pork.
  • Hickory: A classic choice for pork, providing a hearty smoke flavor that’s excellent for bacon and ham.

3. Chicken

  • Apple: The mild, sweet flavor of apple wood is a perfect match for the delicate taste of chicken.
  • Cherry: Provides a sweet and fruity smoke, enhancing chicken’s flavor without overwhelming it.
  • Pecan: Offers a nutty and sweet smoke, adding depth to chicken’s mild flavor.

4. Turkey

  • Cherry: The sweetness of cherry wood complements turkey’s lean meat, especially for holiday roasts.
  • Maple: Imparts a mild, sweet smoke that pairs well with turkey, enhancing its natural flavors.
  • Oak: For a stronger smoke flavor, oak pellets can add richness to turkey meat.

5. Fish

  • Alder: Traditionally used for smoking salmon, alder provides a light, slightly sweet smoke.
  • Apple: The sweetness of apple wood pairs well with the delicate flavors of fish.
  • Cherry: Offers a mild and fruity smoke, suitable for enhancing the taste of lighter fish varieties.

6. Lamb

  • Apple: A sweet and mild smoke that complements lamb’s strong flavors.
  • Hickory: For a more robust smoke flavor, hickory can enhance the rich taste of lamb.
  • Oak: Provides a medium smoke intensity that works well with lamb, balancing its natural flavors.

7. Vegetables

  • Alder: Its mild flavor doesn’t overpower vegetables and is perfect for smoking side dishes.
  • Apple: Adds a hint of sweetness to grilled or smoked vegetables.
  • Pecan: Offers a subtle nutty and sweet flavor, enhancing the natural taste of vegetables.

What About Mixing?

Now, this is a path I have not headed too far down as yet however if you did want to mix and match, then you may be able to open up a whole new range of flavor delicacies. Here is a guide to help you out:

  1. Choose Your Woods: AS we have covered above, different woods impart different flavors. Consider the type of meat or food you’ll be smoking and select woods that complement its flavor.
  2. Consider Flavor Intensity: Some woods, like mesquite and hickory, have a strong flavor, while others like apple and cherry are milder. Balance strong and mild woods to create a nuanced taste.
  3. Experiment with Ratios: Start with a simple 50/50 blend and adjust from there. For a more subtle taste, use more of the milder wood, and for a stronger flavor, increase the percentage of the stronger wood.
  4. Mix Thoroughly: Ensure the pellets are well mixed so that the flavors are evenly distributed.
  5. Test and Adjust: Smoke a small batch of food with your blend to test the flavor (chicken is good for this). Adjust the mix based on your taste preferences and the results.

By experimenting with different woods and ratios, you can create a custom pellet blend that enhances your smoking experience and adds a unique flavor to your dishes.

Check out my: Traeger Signature Pellets Review

Conclusion

So, there you have it, my look into the world of smoker pellets and how you can choose the correct option for your BBQing needs. I hope it has been of assistance but as usual, if you have any questions please do not hesitate to reach out by commenting below.

And of course I would also love to hear below about your experiences with the pellets you prefer in your as well.

Are there any other products you have been looking at but want to know more about? If so, please comment below and I will do my best to get some details for you.

Until next time

Have fun and get smoking!

Paul

Similar Posts

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *